Content:Filecomments: Difference between revisions

From AniDB
Jump to navigation Jump to search
No edit summary
(→‎Special versions: adding HD Remastered version)
 
(82 intermediate revisions by 9 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
__NOTOC__
{{TOCright}}


=File comment standard (workprint)=
==Do NOT...==
*write comments in any other language than English
*add smilies or any off-topic comments
*add comments about download source/patches
*add qpel, gmc, sbc or vfr comments
*add quality ratings to the comments
*add unimportant crap like ''"group xxx 143252643856234758th release"''
*add redundant info like ''"HQ version/LQ version"'' use the freakin' quality rating!


{{eyecatch|Important:| All comments have to be in English!}}
==Content==
===Previously accepted file comments===
{{eyecatch|Note|These comments have their own flag on the video streams now. Use these instead of the file comments.}}
Creditless
Clean Video
3D stereoscopic/3D video/Stereoscopic/..


===Joint episodes===
See: [[Files:Multi-episode_files|Multi episode Files]]


{|cellspacing="4" width="100%"
===Missing content===
|-
There are several files without Intro/Opening, Outro/Ending or Preview. Some people cut them out to save space so they can fit more episodes on one CD.<br>
|width="50%" valign="top"; style="background: #eeeeee; border: 1px solid gray; padding-left:8px; padding-top:5px;padding-right:8px;padding-bottom:5px;"|
But since Intros/Outros are part of the anime/episode we are adding comments about them missing or being incomplete to the file.<br>
Furthermore sometimes scenes get cut out. Missing footage should get reported as well if possible. In such cases set the file to censored as well.


==Additional dubs/subs==
'''Examples:'''
Currently its not possible to add different audio/subtitle combinations to a file than the default ones. So if there is a file with e.g. Japanese, English and Spanish audio only Japanese and English can be added as audio track.<br>
Intro missing
If there is a file with more audio/subtitle tracks you can post a comment about it in the description field.
Outro missing
Preview missing
Intro/Outro/Preview missing
Intro incomplete
Outro incomplete
Preview incomplete
x minute[s] of footage missing (<timecode>) ''<nowiki>*)</nowiki>''
x minute(s) of footage removed by group, to cut out pornography ''<nowiki>*)</nowiki>''


====Examples====
''<nowiki>*)</nowiki> Set "censored" too.''
<small>
Additional dubs: English, German, Italian<br>
Additional subs: Dutch, German, Russian, Spanish
</small>


|width="50%" valign="top"; style="background: #eeeeee; border: 1px solid gray; padding-left:8px; padding-top:5px;padding-right:8px;padding-bottom:5px;"|
===Opening & Endings===
Specification of the content of the op/ed.
{{eyecatch|Note|Meant only for Specials (C)!}}


==External subtitle files==
'''Examples:'''
For some raw videos external subtitle files (.ssa/.srt/.sub&.idx) are available. To make sure people get the right subtitle files for their raw video a comment is added to the subtitle files.
Credits: <Language>
Lyrics: Kanji
Lyrics: Kana
Lyrics: Romaji
Lyrics: English


====Examples====
===Special versions===
<small>
Special versions are "Director's Cuts", "Remastered Versions" and such.<br>
External subtitles for fid xxxx <i>*)</i><br>
If such a special version has a different name, e.g. the "2003 Renewal Edition" of {{a|326|NGE: EoE}}, use that name for the comment.
External subtitles for fid xxxx, yyyy, zzzz<br>
External subtitles for fid xxx1-xxx5<br>
External subtitles for [AHQ] release <i>**)</i>
 
<p><br><i>
<nowiki>*)</nowiki> xxxx represents the fileid (fid) of the video the subtitle file was made for<br>
<nowiki>**)</nowiki> this is only used for big subtitle batches for a whole anime (e.g. O1 Subtitles) atm. might get changed
</i></small>
 
|-
|valign="top"; style="background: #eeeeee; border: 1px solid gray; padding-left:8px; padding-top:5px;padding-right:8px;padding-bottom:5px;"|
 
==Files without intro/outro/preview==
There are several files without Intro/Opening, Outro/Ending or Preview. Some people cut them out to save space so they can fit more episodes on one CD.<br>
But since Intros/Outros are part of the anime/episode we are adding comments about them missing to the file.
 
====Examples====
<small>
Intro missing<br>
Outro missing<br>
Preview missing<br>
Intro/Outro/Preview missing
</small>


|valign="top"; style="background: #eeeeee; border: 1px solid gray; padding-left:8px; padding-top:5px;padding-right:8px;padding-bottom:5px;"|


==Joint episodes==
'''Examples:'''
Joint episodes are <b>official</b> releases of two episodes in one file or when they were aired right after eachother. A recent examples with such "joint episodes" would be [http://anidb.info/a239 Naruto].<br>
Director´s Cut
This is <b>NOT</b> meant for <b>inofficially</b> (e.g. by fansub groups) merged episodes or double episodes from non-japanese DVDs.
Remastered Version
HD Remastered Version (for example, when pre-HD anime from before ~2005 gets re-released in 720p or higher)


====Examples====
===Different Cap Sources for Raws===
<small>
If a raw group puts out 2 full releases of an anime, use file comments to show which file was capped from which source.
Joint episodes 26-27<br>
Example: [http://anidb.net/ag118591 ag118591], ''Gabriel Dropout'' by [Ohys-Raws]. Ohys first capped AT-X, then released a second cap of BS11.
Joint episodes 122-123
</small>


|-
'''Examples:'''
|valign="top"; style="background: #eeeeee; border: 1px solid gray; padding-left:8px; padding-top:5px;padding-right:8px;padding-bottom:5px;"|
Source: AT-X
Source: BS11


==Single-/Multichannel audio==
See also [[Groupentries:Status#Attribution_of_Raws_to_Various_Channel_Sources|here]] for how to report differences in source, when there is only 1 release and the source has changed mid-release.
These comments are meant to tell people if the audio of a file differs from standard 2 channel (stereo) sound.<br>


====Examples====
===Trailer===
<small>
Specification of where the trailer was taken from.
Audio: 1 channel<br>
Audio: 5.1 channel<br>


<i>Dual audio files are to be ignored for the moment as there is no standard for them yet.</i>
'''Examples:'''
</small>
Trailer from official site
Trailer from Special Edition micro-DVD AnimeINC Anniversary


|valign="top"; style="background: #eeeeee; border: 1px solid gray; padding-left:8px; padding-top:5px;padding-right:8px;padding-bottom:5px;"|
==Errors==
For files that contain visible errors or are incomplete (truncated).<br>
Out of the ordinary fps should get reported as well (anything besides: 24,25/29)


==Special versions==
'''Examples:'''
Special versions are "Director's Cuts", "Remastered Versions" and such.<br>
Audio-Video asynchronous (ie when only 1 audio track)
If such a special version has a different name, e.g. the "2003 Renewal Version" of [http://anidb.info/a326 NGE: EoE], use that name for the comment.
English audio track asynchronous with video (iewhen more than 1 track)
Corrupt avi header
Corrupt avi index
Corrupt frames
Corrupt frame[s] (<frames/timecode>)
Corrupt frame[s] (<frames/timecode>; <frames/timecode>; [...])
Corrupt frame[s] (<frames/timecode>-<frames/timecode>)
Corrupt frames (<durance in sec>)
Incomplete file ''<nowiki>*)</nowiki>''


====Examples====
''<nowiki>*)</nowiki> Set quality to "corrupted" as well. In cases like these, the official CRC and the file's actual CRC also usually don't match; double check the status and set it accordingly.''
<small>
Director´s Cut<br>
Remastered Version
</small>


|}
[[Category:Guidelines]]

Latest revision as of 06:06, 22 November 2020

Do NOT...

  • write comments in any other language than English
  • add smilies or any off-topic comments
  • add comments about download source/patches
  • add qpel, gmc, sbc or vfr comments
  • add quality ratings to the comments
  • add unimportant crap like "group xxx 143252643856234758th release"
  • add redundant info like "HQ version/LQ version" use the freakin' quality rating!

Content

Previously accepted file comments

Note These comments have their own flag on the video streams now. Use these instead of the file comments.
Creditless
Clean Video
3D stereoscopic/3D video/Stereoscopic/..

Joint episodes

See: Multi episode Files

Missing content

There are several files without Intro/Opening, Outro/Ending or Preview. Some people cut them out to save space so they can fit more episodes on one CD.
But since Intros/Outros are part of the anime/episode we are adding comments about them missing or being incomplete to the file.
Furthermore sometimes scenes get cut out. Missing footage should get reported as well if possible. In such cases set the file to censored as well.

Examples:

Intro missing
Outro missing
Preview missing
Intro/Outro/Preview missing
Intro incomplete
Outro incomplete
Preview incomplete
x minute[s] of footage missing (<timecode>) *)
x minute(s) of footage removed by group, to cut out pornography *)

*) Set "censored" too.

Opening & Endings

Specification of the content of the op/ed.

Note Meant only for Specials (C)!

Examples:

Credits: <Language>
Lyrics: Kanji
Lyrics: Kana
Lyrics: Romaji
Lyrics: English

Special versions

Special versions are "Director's Cuts", "Remastered Versions" and such.
If such a special version has a different name, e.g. the "2003 Renewal Edition" of NGE: EoE, use that name for the comment.


Examples:

Director´s Cut
Remastered Version
HD Remastered Version (for example, when pre-HD anime from before ~2005 gets re-released in 720p or higher)

Different Cap Sources for Raws

If a raw group puts out 2 full releases of an anime, use file comments to show which file was capped from which source. Example: ag118591, Gabriel Dropout by [Ohys-Raws]. Ohys first capped AT-X, then released a second cap of BS11.

Examples:

Source: AT-X
Source: BS11

See also here for how to report differences in source, when there is only 1 release and the source has changed mid-release.

Trailer

Specification of where the trailer was taken from.

Examples:

Trailer from official site
Trailer from Special Edition micro-DVD AnimeINC Anniversary

Errors

For files that contain visible errors or are incomplete (truncated).
Out of the ordinary fps should get reported as well (anything besides: 24,25/29)

Examples:

Audio-Video asynchronous (ie when only 1 audio track)
English audio track asynchronous with video (iewhen more than 1 track)
Corrupt avi header
Corrupt avi index
Corrupt frames
Corrupt frame[s] (<frames/timecode>)
Corrupt frame[s] (<frames/timecode>; <frames/timecode>; [...])
Corrupt frame[s] (<frames/timecode>-<frames/timecode>)
Corrupt frames (<durance in sec>)
Incomplete file *)

*) Set quality to "corrupted" as well. In cases like these, the official CRC and the file's actual CRC also usually don't match; double check the status and set it accordingly.