staff
235
edits
Talk:Achievements Dev/Archive: Difference between revisions
Mainspace feedback
(Update on ideas sent to main page) |
(Mainspace feedback) |
||
| Line 259: | Line 259: | ||
== Pass #2 == | == Pass #2 == | ||
= Main page feedback = | |||
Thought I'd drop here the questions/notes/comments/feedback I have regarding the mainspace page.<br/><br /> | |||
* Anime achievements | |||
** Is there a difference between "X anime watched" and "X anime episodes watched" in the main page? I noticed you edited some but skipped others. If it's all episode-based, I can put "episode" on everything. | |||
** How are we going to deal with movies and other non-standard episode lengths? Sum up the minutes, or ignore the quirk and move on? | |||
** Are we going to require special episodes, or just regular? I'm personally against special episodes of any kind being in the list; remember there are utterly pointless S episodes, like staff interviews no one gives a fuck about, and other kinds of special episodes are even worse. | |||
** Multi-badges: I think hentai badge 1 does not convey the point. Panty shots can be found like anywhere. I think badge 4 is the best, now with 10000% more censorship (great lulz achieved there). | |||
** Multi-badges: LoGH badge 1 is the best by far. The Galactic Empire's flag is far more easily recognizable than Reinhard's face. Dunno why, I just think it looks ''better''. | |||
** Multi-badges: Macross badge 1, please. I might be biased because I hate Minmay, but yeah.<br/><br /> | |||
* Mylist achievements | |||
** Multi-badges: The watched eps badge 1 is much better than the second. It's fairly obvious that there's TV watching going on in badge 1, whereas in badge 2 you need to look closely to see the remote control. That's a remote control, right? :) | |||
** Multi-badges: I prefer badge 2 for time wasted, for not being anime-specific, and being generally awesome. <philosophical> Also because watching anime warps your senses of time. ;) </philosophical><br/><br /> | |||
* Statistical achievements | |||
** Multi-badges: No poo pic for avdumped files. It's funny and all, but it's a bit of a stretch. It might also be NSFW and offensive to sensitive tards. | |||
** Multi-badges: I don't really get the review pics... Explain? | |||
** Multi-badges: AniDB member pic 1, because it's much funnier. | |||
** Does the collector for user rank, level 1, consider the whatever maintainers who aren't modreport checkers? | |||
*** Currently 4 people are set as (non-adv.) users with char relation maintainer status. At least one of them has to deserve the user rank badge more than I do. :)<br/><br /> | |||
* One-time achievements: | |||
** Multi-badges: Introduction in forum: pic 1 because Oosaka is much better that way. :P (Fuck, I can't remember her real name! LOL!) | |||
** What's the collector? Making a thread there? I'm fairly sure I never made a thread there, but I'm well over 2k posts and I replied to a few thread in that forum. Never too late, I guess... I'll make a mental note to get around to it some time or other. :D<br/><br /> | |||
* Special achievements: | |||
** Multi-badges: contributing code badge 2, because what's more associated with code than the Matrix? Unrelated: the other badge kind of reminds me of GITS:SAC, but I don't think that's where it comes from.<br/><br /> | |||
* Possibility of hiding specific achievements if the user wants to? | |||
** For instance, users might not want others to have even a clue how much anime they have while still allowing them to see the userpage, so we might want to block anime and mylist achievements. | |||
*** That's particularly true for 18+ anime, which have a hiding option of their own in the profile. | |||
*** The badges could be displayed according to the viewer's permission to see the user's data, which would solve that problem. | |||
**** Another possibility would be having a hiding option "see badges from my userpage" in the profile, which may or may not obey the other restrictions, pending discussion. | |||
** Is there any badge we might want to make un-hideable?<br/><br /> | |||
* More to come?<br/><br /> | |||
--[[User:Hinoe|Hinoe]] 03:21, 17 January 2012 (CET) | |||