1,633
edits
Review comments: Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
m
no edit summary
mNo edit summary |
mNo edit summary |
||
| (One intermediate revision by the same user not shown) | |||
| Line 5: | Line 5: | ||
== How to comment == | == How to comment == | ||
Screeny of page, post etc. | Screeny of page, post etc. | ||
{{eyecatch|Note|Line breaks didn't work previously, long comments from a while ago might be a little hard to read}} | {{eyecatch|Note|Line breaks didn't work previously, long comments from a while ago might be a little hard to read.}} | ||
== Comment guidelines == | == Comment guidelines == | ||
Comments and votes should be based on the quality of the review, not your agreement or disagreement with the writer's opinion on the anime. Some useful questions to ask: | Comments and votes should be based on the quality of the review, not your agreement or disagreement with the writer's opinion on the anime. Some useful questions to ask: | ||
| Line 24: | Line 22: | ||
*Did the reviewer watch the entire series, or enough to establish a legitimate perspective on the anime? | *Did the reviewer watch the entire series, or enough to establish a legitimate perspective on the anime? | ||
*Does the review express himself or herself clearly? | *Does the review express himself or herself clearly? | ||
{{eyecatchLight|1|Note|Some commenters believe it's appropriate to judge reviews on grammar and spelling and grasp of the English language, while others believe these issues are aside from the point as long as the reviewer can make a coherent statement.}} | |||
Based on questions like these, you should assign a vote and comment on why you chose the vote you did. The available votes are: | Based on questions like these, you should assign a vote and comment on why you chose the vote you did. The available votes are: | ||